Mon 24 Aug, 2009
The specter of debate about health care reform has significant social ramifications. Much has been said about the lack of civility in the August discussions, especially in town hall meetings, about proposed health care reforms. Rather than engaging in debate, spectators at town hall meetings have been shouting down their representatives, especially if the latter support some form of health care reform. cable television commentators have enjoyed the ruckus, to use President Obama’s phrase, which is obviously quite good for ratings. There has been much talk about mis-information, and some disdain, but not enough in my view, to folks who feel compelled to bring firearms to these public meetings. we have heard of old folks who received Medicare, a government program, who are against goverment-run health care, not to mention the famous death panels, claims of Nazism and social movements paid for by healthcare interests and those who want to derail President Obama’s agenda. From CNN we get the hyperbolic: “August, the make or break month for health care.”
This hype goes on and on, but it pushes into the background a more serious issue–that of the valorization of ignorance in contemporary American culture. There is such incendiary pablum on the airwave, pablum that is taken as “tribal truth,” which, even if it is patently false, is still maintained. Such a sad process makes me think that a portion of our population has been drugged with less than half-truths. The same process underscores just how ill-informed our population has become. If my students are indicative–and they are a tad more curious than most of their fellow citizens–then we’ve become a nation of people who lack curiosity about the world, who find thinking to be painful, who don’t take time to read or, God-forbid, have a critical reflection about the world around them. When I read that only a small percentage of Americans have passports and that a surprising percentage of our fellow citizens have never been outside the US and have little interest in traveling to other countries and knowing a tad more about the world, it reinforces my impression, reinforced by many of undergraduate students, that we suffer from a tragic parochialism, which, in itself, is a sign of social decline.
I worry about the future and hope that my pessimistic assessment of our culture of ignorance will be proven wrong. Time will tell.
Matthew Hynes says:
Hey Dr. Stoller,
Hope you remember me. I graduated last fall from WCU. I am writing this from China (Long Gang to be exact). youtube is a no-no here but we can catch the Daily Show on the internet. The Debate is sad, no? It seems to me the Town Hall shout-down demographic has always existed, but now they’ve been galvanized by this single issue (I lived in PA during the Clinton Era, those days don’t seem so long ago as they once did). Really, this goes beyond Healthcare. This seems to be more about what role Government should play in the lives of its citizens. living in the PRC has given me a whole new perspective on such an argument. It would take my own blog to fully explore these ideas and the differences between the USA and PRC’s perception of State control. write me an email when you get the chance! (Arock467@yahoomail.co)
Mateo Kupstys Chica says:
Dr Stoller,
I have been thinking about the virtuality of the western world some time ago. Your post reminds me of an issue I lived in Munich, at the ethnology and africanistic institute. I remember there was a group of students discussing about what they could do, to help X country in Africa that was suffering form civil war. I asked them, if they knew or talked to the stewards from the institute’s kitchen. They nodded, although they had seen them. They where immigrants from Africa, who got asylum in Germany. I found funny that they where thinking about helping a whole country, thousands of Km away from Germany, but where unconscious of the people near them, the ones they could talk with, or help… or at least to hear THEIR point of view of the situation. But that’s too difficult. One (especially ethno/anthropo-logists) needs cognitive humbleness; the courage to accept, that one could be wrong about the idea of the world… specially if it’s nourished by the media. Most people seem to wanna change the world, but, if the world is a description, a cultural reality… wouldn’t it be more easy to change our perception of it?
Great post! Tkx for posting!
Mateo Kupstys Chica
TYRONE says:
Buy:Zyban.Valtrex.Zovirax.Mega Hoodia.Accutane.Nexium.100% Pure Okinawan Coral Calcium.Prednisolone.Synthroid.Retin-A.Actos.Petcam (Metacam) Oral Suspension.Human Growth Hormone.Lumigan.Prevacid.Arimidex….
DONNIE says:
Buy:Soma.VPXL.Zithromax.Cialis Soft Tabs.Viagra Soft Tabs.Viagra Professional.Tramadol.Levitra.Cialis Super Active+.Viagra.Viagra Super Active+.Maxaman.Super Active ED Pack.Viagra Super Force.Cialis Professional.Cialis.Propecia….